What to wear, what to wear…
September 7th, 2008Your hypothetical panel that is.
The final finish you choose for any woodworking should not be a decision taken lightly, and a few truths might help (or hinder) that decision making process. Some basic, unavoidable facts might also change your perspective on what maketh a good finish for your work and how you finish what you need to do and what you can let slide.
Firstly, the contenders. Not a complete list, and in no particular order.
The oils. This is reserved strictly for true oils, not modified or altered oils. Also included here are waxes.
Varnishes and oil/varnish blends.
Lacquer and shellac, the evaporative finishes.
Other finishes, few (if any) of which are doable outside the professional workshop.
The true oils include boiled linseed oil (aka:BLO), tung oil and other oils that polymerise upon contact with oxygen. They are very simple to use because you simply apply it, and remove any excess. They also help to make any interesting wood look better by making the grain ‘pop’ which simply means it highlights the figure present in the grain of the wood. They also give a very natural ‘in the wood’ appearance. The downsides are that they take a long time to dry, the time varies depending on which oil you choose and this time is measured in days, not hours. They offer minimal mechanical protection against abrasion and bumps and they do not resist moisture or solvents.
Having said all that, they are very popular and so have the runs on the board historically.
I use BLO for things that are not too important like my own tools and things I wish to keep protected from grime from my hands and dust. When it is a little more important, I use Perilla oil. This is a very fast drying oil derived from a flower and it is one of the most durable oils available. It is also very uncommon outside of Asia and is more expensive than BLO or tung oil. I like it because it dries within 24 hours no matter the weather, it does not excessively darken the wood and it smells much nicer than the strong odour of BLO.
Waxes include beeswax and carnauba wax. They are very similar to the oils in application, offer even less protection against mechanical injury but can resist moisture more than the oils do. As a finish they are popular enough, but they need more maintenance than any other finish. I only use wax on tools and jigs that need something on them to allow my workpieces to slide easily. I don’t use wax as a finish alone, I usually use it as something over a finish to make the final product look and feel a little bit better.
Varnishes are basically oils that have been altered so that they polymerise faster and the molecules form longer chains than occur in true oils. In simpler terms, they dry much faster and are much tougher than true oils.Varnishes are available with an oil or water base, but the final end finish is mostly the same protection wise but the water based varnishes are typically clear and the oil based with a yellow/orange hue to them.
Because they are made from oil, you can mix the oil based varnishes with oil and get a finish that lies somewhere in between the toughness of varnish but with the easy application and natural appearance of true oils. Finishes like Danish oil and ‘Tung oil finish’ are typically oil/varnish blends. The ratio of oil to varnish alters it’s working properties and protective qualities toward the higher percentage constituent.
Varnishes can offer protection against moisture, heat and solvents once they have cured. Polyurethanes are some of the more common varnishes in use today and with good reason. They are extremely durable once they are fully cured (at week or two at least), resist mechanical, heat and solvent damage to a high degree and are fairly easy to use.
The downsides are few, but significant. Because they are closely related to oils, their drying time is still quite long. Touch dry is typically within a few hours, but full cure takes quite a long time just as it does with the true oils. Because of the slower drying time, the finishing area needs to be free of dust and the work needs to be thoroughy cleaned of dust and contaminants. Because varnishes tend to be quick viscous (thick, like cream rather than milk) they can be difficult to get a good, smooth finish from a brush or other hand applications and to compound this, the long curing time means that smoothing out the lumps and bumps is usually done on a semi cured and quite soft finish which makes sandpaper clog quite quickly.
I do like varnish, even with it’s troubles. There are some tricks to using varnish successfully, and I will explain mine later.
The current panel is getting and oil based varnish finish, chosen more for it’s durability than any other reason.
The evaporative finishes are lacquer and shellac. These are resin based rather than oil based, and are dissolved in solvent to make them liquid. Once the solvent evaporates, you are left with the resin as your finish. Shellac uses alcohol as it’s solvent, and lacquer uses a petrochemical solvent, most commonly tagged as ‘lacquer thinner’. How original…
Because the solvents used evaporate quickly, these finishes dry very, very fast. The drying time is measured in minutes, not hours or days. Once dry, they are done. They is no further action in the finish unlike the curing of oils or varnishes. For these reasons, both shellac and varnish are very popular but from two very different angles.
Shellac is, quite possibly ‘the perfect finish’. It can be applied by brushing, wiping, spraying or dipping. The solvent is environmentally and person friendly (being alcohol, hiccup). It is safe to eat (often found on medicines to seal them) and can be obtained in shades from water clear to a deep amber. It is easy to repair and can take an extremely high polish.
Wonderful stuff, but as usual there are caveats…
Because it is simply resin in solvent, it can and will always be damaged by that solvent, in this case, alcohol. Something quite low in alcohol can harm it, like beer (although American beers might be ok). It has little resistance to heat and moisture. A cup of coffee set upon it is almost guaranteed to harm a shellacked surface.
Perfect, it aint. Not by a long way.
Lacquer is very similar to shellac. Again it can be applied by brushing, wiping, dipping or spraying. It has high clarity and does not obscure the grain of the wood. It is easily repaired and can also be polished to a very high level with ease. It also dries exceptionally fast, even faster than shellac. This can cause problems when brushing or wiping, which makes lacquer more likely to be sprayed.
The solvent, lacquer thinner, is far less friendly but also less likely to be encountered by furniture. It has greater resistance to moisture and heat, although excessive heat can still damage a lacquer finish. As a result, lacquer is much more durable than shellac, but is less easy to work with and not as safe to use.
Japanese and Chinese lacquer is not the same as the ‘usual’ lacquer used in woodworking. It comes from a tree, and fits in somewhere between normal lacquer and varnish. It is one of the more difficult finishes to use, but is highly resistant to damage and extremely beautiful. It is also hideously expensive and best left to sado-masochistic types and experts in it’s use.
Finally, the specialist coatings. Usually these are two part finishes and require special equipment to use them. If they are available to you, then there is little point in my explaining them, and if you can’t use them then don’t look here for answers because I don’t have any.
If I need to use these, I will send my stuff out to be finished. Fewer headaches that way, figuratively and literally…
So, that’s what we got to choose from when it comes to finishing our panel. It is time for me to get out of here, so I let that simmer for a little while before we get back.
I am using oil based urethane varnish on the big panel, and I will be explaining how I went about it and some trick I have found along the way.
Thanks for reading,
Stu.